Monday, November 07, 2011

Newt's daughter's back story on his divorce

From our "For What It's Worth" department, "About that story where Newt Gingrich served divorce papers on his wife while she was in the hospital ..." (Lex Communis, November 3, 2011): "... totally bogus, according to his daughter," who writes:
My mother and father were already in the process of getting a divorce, which she requested.

Dad took my sister and me to the hospital to see our mother. She had undergone surgery the day before to remove a tumor. The tumor was benign.
Read more >>

[Hat tip to C.B.]

Anglican order of nuns becomes Catholic

Deacon Greg Kandra reports at Deacon's Bench (November 6, 2011).

[Hat tip to C.B.]

A side of George W. Bush the drive-by media didn't see

A plagiarism scandal forced Timothy Goeglein to resign in 2008 from former President George W. Bush's administration. Christianity Today magazine interviewed him (published November 3, 2011):
What happened after a reporter revealed that you had plagiarized?

When you embarrass the President, a divorce takes place. You become persona non grata immediately. Through my own fault, no pressure, no stress, no extenuating circumstances, because of what I did and the choices I made, I inflicted shame and embarrassment on the man who has given me the greatest professional opportunity of my life. I inflicted shame and embarrassment on my wife, my children, my 20 years of interns—I was a total hypocrite—and I resigned.

How did President Bush react?

I resigned, no excuses, on a Friday. On a Monday I came in to take the pictures off my wall and clear off my desk, and I received a call from the chief of staff, Josh Bolton. He asked me how my wife and children were doing and told me he forgave me. He said, "The boss wants to see you." That means the President. When I got there, it was just the President and me, and I apologized. He looked at me and said "Tim, I forgive you." I tried to apologize a second time, and he said, "Grace and mercy is real. I've known it in my life and I'm sending it to you." And I said, "Mr. President, I apologize. Please forgive me." He said, "I'll say it again: Grace and mercy is real. You are forgiven. Now we can talk about all of this, or we can talk about the last eight years." We spent 20 minutes together. We prayed and we embraced. I cried when I was looking around the Oval Office for the last time. And as I prepared to leave he said, "By the way, I want you to bring your wife and sons here so I can tell them what a great husband and father you've been." Sure enough, he invited them to come. He was the leader of the free world, validating me, after I did what I did, before my wife and children. (emphasis added)
[Hat tip to C.B.]

Sunday, November 06, 2011

On Jimmy Fallon's preference for traditional Catholicism


Boniface, in "Jimmy Fallon Prefers Traditional Catholicism" (Unam Sanctam Catholicam, October 24, 2011), writes:
Did anybody happen to catch the NPR interview with Jimmy Fallon on "Fresh Air" the other day? It was quite interesting. After a lot of banter about his television program and Saturday Night Live, he talked about his upbringing as a Catholic in the 1980s. Unlike a lot of popular comedians who were raised Catholic, Fallon had nothing negative to say about Catholicism whatsoever. He said that he was very grateful for his Catholic upbringing and loved everything about the Church - he loved Catholic school (St. Mary of the Snow in Saugerties, NY), loved the nuns, loved going to Mass, loved receiving at the rail, and loved the way attending Mass made him feel. He even shared that he had been an altar server, revered and looked up to his parish priest and had once believed he had a vocation to the priesthood. This sort of warm praise of Catholicism was a very welcome thing to hear from a pop comedian.

But even more interesting was when the host, Terry Gross, asked him if he was still a practicing Catholic. Fallon explained that, as often happens, the practice of his faith waned during his teen years. He ended up getting into show business and moved out to Los Angeles. There, around the mid-ninties, he tried to attend Mass again but complained that the Mass had "changed" from the Irish-Catholic Masses he knew as a boy in Saugerties. Among his complaints: the atmosphere was way too casual, there was a rock band playing, people were holding hands constantly, and (tongue in cheek of course, or hopefully) he complained about frisbees being thrown around. This, he said, was not Mass. He went on to say how he cherished the old Mass - the bells, the incense, the kneelers and the aesthetic it all created. Then, in the one quote I can recall with certainty from the interview, he said that he totally disapproved of Mass with all the "bells and whistles," following that up by saying, "Just give me the Mass."

It was inspiring, but also sad, because this experience of an apparently ultra-banal Novus Ordo in the L.A. diocese turned him away from the practice of his faith and, though he still considers himself Catholic, he no longer attends Mass at all. Sure, Fallon is ultimately responsible for whether or not he fulfills his Sunday obligation, but I'd have to think, when stuff like this happens, the persons responsible for these abominable liturgies also share the blame.

Also interesting is what more "traditional" Mass it is that Fallon is remembering so fondly. As someone born in 1974, he never knew the pre-1969 liturgy. It sounds like what he experienced as a boy was simply the Novus Ordo done more or less according to the rubrics in one of New York's more historic churches. He recalls nuns, communion rails, and incense, and this all in the late eighties!
[Hat tip to J.M.]

Boniface: "I am mad" about Assisi

Boniface writes, over at Unam Sanctam Catholicam (October 28, 2011): "I am mad. More than mad, fuming. So, we were supposed to not get upset about Assisi III? We were supposed to trust that the indiscretions of Assisi I and Assisi II under John Paul "the Great" would not be repeated at Assisi III .... Pray. Do penance. Preach the truth. This nonsense has to stop...."

[Hat tip to J.M.]

Scaring liberals on Halloween

H. W. Crocker III, an author whose naughty sense of humor I naughtily approve, has given us another gift, this one apparently well in time for Halloween, even though this reporting is somewhat after the fact. In "How to Scare a Liberal to Death" (NRO, October 26, 2011), he offers several juicy suggestions about possible costumes to don for trick-or-treating in neighborhoods infested with blithely smug political liberals:
Nothing offends liberals more than colonialism. It is, in their eyes, racism, sexism, and chauvinism all in one; it is the forcible imposition of Christianity and capitalism; it is the epitome of Western triumphalism. It is everything that leftists profess to hate.

So, what better costumes to don for Halloween than those of great British imperialists throughout the centuries? ...
Read more >>

[Hat tip to J.M.]

Wednesday, November 02, 2011

Eine feste Burg ist Luther?

While not a convert from Lutheranism, I spent over twenty years of my life among more-or-less Lutheran colleagues at an ELCA university, and if I were to count two of my childhood years boarding with a Missouri-Synod missionary family while attending an international school my parents sent me to in Sapporo, Japan, the number of years would run even higher. Like Garrison Keillor of Prairie Home Companion, we know all the Lutheran jokes, including those about Sven and Ole and their cousins, Ole and Lena.

I have watched a generation of old guard Lutherans suffer through the implosion of their denomination after the merger of three erstwhile Lutheran denominations into the ELCA in 1988. In 2009, the ELCA Churchwide Assembly in Minneapolis voted to allow congregations to call and ordain gays and lesbians in committed monogamous relationships to serve as clergy. Seeing the writing on the wall years earlier, conservative Lutheran clergy and laity have been bailing out, forming new denominations, going east to Orthodoxy or swimming the Tiber and becoming Catholics. The ranks of the latter have included the likes of the late Fr. Richard John Neuhaus, Robert Wilken, Bruce Marshall, Reinhard Huetter, Leonard Klein, David Fagerberg, and Mickey Mattox, prompting Carl E. Braaten to write an open letter to his bishop in 2005 about an ELCA "brain drain."

Another former Lutheran, Fr. John Zuhlsdorf, wrote yesterday in a post, "Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott" (WDTPRS, November 1, 2011):
I, a former Lutheran, think all readers of the Fishwrap should pay special attention to this post I picked up from Fr. Longenecker.

These ... what do you call them ... incongruities? ... exist in order to make irony redundant.

This, friends, is where the liberal agenda will take Catholics:
In celebration of Reformation Day I thought readers might like this photograph of the heirs of Luther:


That would be Lutheran bishop of Stockholm Eva Brunne on the left. Eva is in a 'registered and blessed' homosexual partnership. She and her 'partner' have a child conceived through artificial insimination.
Fr. Z adds:
I remember how in [Catholic] seminary I was forced, over my objections and with realistic threats of expulsion from the faculty, to go to a Lutheran church on [R]eformation [Day] and sing as part of a choir “A mighty fortress is our God”.
Redundant ironies indeed.

Questions for seminarians

Fr. Zuhlsdorf solicits anonymous feedback: "Questions for seminarians" (WDTPRS, November 2, 2011):
As we know, Universae Ecclesiae spoke to the need for Latin Church seminarians to know the Extraordinary Form.

I would appreciate notes by email from seminarians about what is going on in their programs of formation.

I will of course preserve your anonymity.
On the linked post, Fr. Z gives instructions on how to reach him and offer feedback.

Occupiers: so many costs in such little time



[Hat tip to Fr. Z.]

Cardinal Pell helping FSSP raise funds for its house in Sydney

Check it out!

Get your plenary indulgence today ~ and tell a Lutheran

Nov. 2nd, of course, is a wonderful day to get yourself a plenary indulgence. Visit a cemetery and pray for the faithful departed; go to a church and pray a Pater Noster and recite the Credo for the intentions of the Holy Father; go to Mass today or within a few days; make a good confession on the same day that you assist at Mass; and make sure you are free of all attachment to sin. The Catholic equivalent of frequent-flyer miles, as our Master of Ceremonies reminds us! =)

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Fr. Z on an instance of sacrilege at Assisi III

Nothing overblown, no goats or chickens sacrificed, but a few incisive remarks about a video clip of a "Pagan chant to the deity Olokun in the Basilica of St. Francis during Assisi III" (WDTPRS, October 28, 2011).

As Father says: "For pity’s sake, couldn’t the organizers learned from the mistakes made at Assisi I, back in the day?"

But see also the address of Pope Benedict XVI at Assisi.

Bishop Slattery: "They shouldn't have viewed the old liturgy...as something that needed to be fixed."

Bishop Edward Slattery, in an interview with the National Catholic Register (October 28, 2011), responded to a question about problems with the liturgy and what changes he would like to see with the following:
I would like to see the liturgy become what Vatican II intended it to be. That’s not something that can happen overnight. The bishops who were the fathers of the council from the United States came home and made changes too quickly. They shouldn’t have viewed the old liturgy, what we call the Tridentine Mass or Missal of Pope John XXIII, as something that needed to be fixed. Nothing was broken. There was an attitude that we had to implement Vatican II in a way that radically affects the liturgy.

What we lost in a short period of time was continuity. The new liturgy should be clearly identifiable as the liturgy of the pre-Vatican II Church. Changes, like turning the altar around, were too sudden and too radical. There is nothing in the Vatican II documents that justifies such changes. We’ve always had Mass facing the people as well as Mass ad orientem [“to the east,” with priest and people facing the same direction]. However, Mass ad orientem was the norm. These changes did not come from Vatican II.

Also, it was not a wise decision to do away with Latin in the Mass. How that happened, I don’t know; but the fathers of the Council never intended us to drop Latin. They wanted us to hold on to it and, at the same time, to make room for the vernacular, primarily so that the people could understand the Scriptures.
His Excellency goes on to say that he has himself begun celebrating Mass ad orientem, leading by example rather than by dictate. Most importantly, he declares:
But we must approach the liturgy on bended knee with tremendous humility, recognizing that it doesn’t belong to us. It belongs to God. It is a gift. We worship God not by creating our own liturgies, but by receiving the liturgy as it comes to us from the Church.
A point, surely, that needs to be reiterated throughout the Church these days.

[Hat tip to Rorate Caeli]

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Ominous signs: state repression of religion on its way

Russell Shaw, "Are we seeing the beginning of religious persecution in America?" (OSV Newsweekly, November 6, 2011): "Is America on track for a religious freedom crisis generated by secularists in and out of government bent on pushing churches around on a variety of fronts? Fresh evidence strongly suggests that the answer is yes."

[Hat tip to Fr. Zuhlsdorff]

Comments about Communion in the hand attributed to St. Cyril a deception?

Rev. Fr. Giuseppe Pace, S.D.B., has published an article, "S. Cirillo di Gerusalemme e la Comunione sulla mano" Chiesa Viva (January 1990) (Civiltà, Brescia.), arguing that the words attributed to St. Cyril of Jerusalem ("When thou goest to receive communion ... [place] thy left hand as a throne for thy right, ... to receive so great a King, and in the hollow of the palm receive the body of Christ, saying, Amen") are an historical deception promoted by a crypto-Arian.

The author, says the article, was "an anonymous Syrian, a devourer of books, an indefatigable writer who poured into his writings, indigested and contaminated figments of own his imagination" -- whose writings became part of the Mystagogical Catechesis through the work of a successor of St. Cyril, who most scholars identify as "Bishop John," a crypto-Arian, influenced by Origen and Pelagius and thus contested by Sts. Epiphanius, Jerome, and Augustine.

A translation by Rorate contributor Francesca Romana is available under the title of "The great Catholic horror story: the pseudo-historical deception of Communion in the hand" (Rorate Caeli, Octobwer 26, 2011).

It will be interesting to hear what the patristic scholars have to say about this.